Pretty soon, you’ll no longer be able to jam out out to ABBA classics on Broadway. Mamma Mia! will end on September 5 after 14 years on Broadway, the show’s creator Judy Grayner announced on Thursday. It’ll close up shop after 5,765 performances, making it the eighth-longest-running show ever on Broadway. Start booking your tickets now! (Or you can always just watch the movie. Meryl Streep FTW!)