As a rule, Valentine’s Day gifts should feel indulgent and sexy. But that doesn’t mean they have to be a huge splurge. Even if your giftee has expensive tastes, little luxuries like a sterling-silver nutcracker or designer nail polish can make a big impact on a (relatively small) budget. To that end, we’ve rounded up 33 of the cheapest, nicest things from the most expensive brands that will make your Valentine feel rich and glamorous without draining your savings account.
Update on February 12, 2025: Replaced the nearly sold-out croissant charm from Claire V. with a similar sardine charm; added a porcelain trinket box from Italian luxury brand Ginori 1735; updated prices and checked stock for all products.
Though they are affordable compared to most of the other gifts on this list, Jellycat stuffies are pricey compared to most other plush toys. The brand’s adorable stuffed vegetables, pastries, and other critters will usually run you somewhere between $30 and $200. That makes this pear-shaped Christmas ornament — which could easily double as a bag charm — a steal at just $15.
Loewe’s tomato-scented bar soap is both affordable-ish and an emerging status symbol among hand soaps.
If the fine jewelry or leather handbags from L.A.-based Clare V. are too expensive, this sweet little 14-karat-gold-plated sardine charm is an excellent alternative.
It may be just 2.48 inches tall, but this porcelain trinket box from Italian luxury brand Ginori 1735 is no small gift. The lid features an illustration by artist Luke Edward Hall inspired by the Cotswolds, the Hamptons of England.
Sure, it’s a lot for a scrunchie, but Sandy Liang’s oversize flower design will make an impact on any outfit, and it’s the kind of accessory that can gain you entry into a certain cool-girl milieu.
I love how this beanie from luxury fashion house Kenzo is stark and whimsical at the same time.
A fancy pencil — like this one from British luxury stationer Smythson — livens up boring tasks like making to-do lists and taking notes.
Designer John Derian sells a wide range of accessories, decor, and home goods, many of which cost upwards of several thousand dollars. But these decoupaged portable mirrors — you can choose from 200 designs — are very affordable and would make an excellent Valentine’s day gift.
Wearing anything from the Japanese brand Kapital is always a flex, and these socks with smiles on the heels are super-soft and durable — I’ve been wearing my hemp-and-cotton-blend socks from the brand for over five years now.
I love this cheeky T-shirt from high-end fashion label Vaquera. And considering the brand sells a pair of boxers for over $300, this tee is a good deal.
Arc’Teryx’s investment-worthy winter coats are some of the warmest you’ll find, and the brand’s shoes, clothing, and gear are beloved by fashion people and celebrities for their sleek design. This hat is a steal compared to the cost of a jacket, and it’s currently selling fast after Timothé Chalamet recently wore one in New York.
This silk scarf from Coach is a stylish alternative to the brand’s much costlier leather bags.
Even if you don’t have Chanel-suit money, this much cheaper bottle of Chanel nail polish is a delightful gift that your Valentine can wear every day.
If your giftee lusts after Doen, they’ll appreciate this understated headband topped with a sweet bow.
Fancy underwear is a classic Valentine’s Day gift. This baby-pink pair from La Perla is sexy but not over the top.
Sunspel is known for its luxury basics that last, making these the holy grail of cotton boxers. They are also among the most affordable products you can get from the brand.
An upgrade for their everyday hoops, from cool-girl favorite designer Rachel Comey.
Corridor’s clothing exemplifies actually stylish quiet luxury, with much of the brand’s wares designed and manufactured in New York. I love this cotton hat emblazoned with a double callout to the city.
An eye-catching reusable bag featuring Marimekko’s iconic Unikko print, for much less than the brand’s iconic dresses or even one of its T-shirts.
Buck Mason makes some of the softest and nicest-looking T-shirts for both men and women. This tank isn’t that much cheaper than the brand’s other tees, but it is the one I have gotten the most wear out of over the last five years. It’s also about half the price of the brand’s long-sleeves.
You may not be open to spending $600 on a shirt for your Valentine. But if they happen to be a new (and particularly fashionable) dad, they’ll love this baby Bode shirt from the menswear darling.
Kids’ brand Mini Rodini is a status symbol among well-to-do creative-leaning parents. And the quality and clever designs drive up the cost of even the most basic items. You’ll get the most for your money with this set of funky ocean-themed socks.
A sleek, heart-shaped gadget from Italian home-and-kitchen design giant Alessi, for especially elegant nut-splitting.
Smeg is known for splurge-y refrigerators, but it also makes a nice-looking electric kettle that you can get for several hundred dollars less. It’s available in a range of colors and made of double-walled steel so the outside of the kettle stays cool even when the water inside is piping hot.
You can’t go wrong with a subtle fig-scented soap from French perfumer Diptyque.
A little luxury for the dog in your life, from New York–based designer Susan Alexandra.
Foot care from Birkenstock to prep their feet for Birkenstock season.
There’s some major high-low appeal to this leather Little Miss Sunshine charm from leather-goods brand Maison de Sabré. It even has a mini zip pocket that can hold a few coins or an Apple Airtag.
Elsa Peretti’s designs for Tiffany & Co. can run into the thousands, but this chic apple bookmark costs less than $100 and would be a nice treat for an avid reader.
A useful and adorable addition to any Le Creuset collection, especially if your Valentine’s love language involves home-cooked meals.
This shiny Saint Laurent travel mug will add some glam to their morning coffee run — though if gold is too ostentatious, it also comes in black and silver.
The Strategist is a new site designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best notebook, black T-shirts, fashion-editor-approved jeans, toothbrush, and apartment décor. Note that all prices are subject to change.
If you buy something through our links, New York may earn an affiliate commission.
