Amy Sedaris stopped by The Colbert Report last night to show off an amazing cookie recipe from her book Simple Things that is sure to be a hit at the holiday office party — plus it can detect which of your co-workers are liars. Over on Chelsea Lately, Chelsea Handler could care less about Taylor Momsen’s thoughts on the topic of masturbation, and Conan O’Brien is ready for Jimmy Carter’s gay president, on Conan. Wrapping things up on Late Night with Jimmy Fallon, Jimmy interrupts Jon Lovitz’s tribute song to him and Conan right when things are about to get a little awkward. Watch our compilation to see what you missed.