Steve Carell might be an Oscar nominee this year, but he still likes to keep himself in check now and then, so during last night’s Late Show he shared an online critic’s review of his first sitcom role in the short-lived ABC series Over the Top, which was so harsh that Stephen Colbert offered the critic a writing job at The Colbert Report. Watch Carell and Letterman talk about Anchorman and Carell’s Oscar nomination below: